🠄 Back to blog

AI, Open Source, and the Path Ahead

2025-01-21

Artificial intelligence is rapidly reshaping our world, impacting every facet of society (economy, geostrategy, war, democracy, even shaping the way we think as human beings). As Europe charts its course in this tumultuous transformative era, we, at EuroStack, believe that open source is crucial pillar for innovation, competitiveness, and digital sovereignty. This powerful combination offers a unique opportunity to build today a digital Europe aligned with its core values: fairness, accountability, transparency, and inclusivity.

AI and Open Source: A Symbiotic Relationship

AI's transformative impact is undeniable, with applications from streamlining operations to enabling groundbreaking discoveries. Most AI software (tools, frameworks, libraries...) used today in this transformation are open source, including machine learning and deep learning libraries, and we're witnessing the emerge of "open source AI models". The collaboration around these projects fuels innovation, allowing developers across Europe and beyond to build upon existing technologies, tailor solutions to specific needs, and contribute to a growing body of knowledge.

The Strategic Importance of Open Source

Open source is far more than just a licensing model; it's a strategic asset that empowers Europe to:

  • Control its digital destiny: By embracing open source, Europe can reduce its reliance on proprietary technologies from non-European tech giants, fostering greater independence and control over critical digital infrastructure. Open source models, code, and tools are key to self-sufficiency.
  • Foster a competitive digital ecosystem: Open source promotes a level playing field, enabling startups, SMEs, and established businesses to innovate and compete on an equal footing. It breaks down barriers to entry and reduces the risk of vendor lock-in. Several successful projects (e.g. scikit-learn) were notably initiated and/or led in Europe.
  • Ensure transparency and trust: Openness is intrinsically linked to trust. The transparency of open source code allows for thorough scrutiny, fostering accountability and enabling the identification and mitigation of potential biases or security vulnerabilities. This is especially important for AI, as "responsible and trustworthy" AI (as defined by the EU) requires transparency and accountability.
  • Drive responsible AI development: The principles of open source align perfectly with the call for ethical AI. By making AI models and training datasets more accessible, we can foster greater understanding, scrutiny, and ultimately, more responsible AI.
  • Safeguard European values: In an increasingly data-driven world, open source provides a powerful mechanism to protect privacy, promote fairness, and ensure that technology serves the public good. Open source models are key to escaping surveillance-based business models, for example.

Regulation and Responsibility

Europe's proactive approach to regulating AI, exemplified by the AI Act, is commendable. It recognizes the need for a human-centric approach that safeguards fundamental rights while fostering innovation. Open source is also affected by such regulations, in sometimes "invisible" ways. The ongoing evolution of this regulatory landscape / landmine highlights the importance of involving the open source community (including the Open Source AI subcommunity) to ensure that regulations are effective and do not inadvertently stifle innovation.

The AI Act's recognition of open source's specificities is a positive step. However, challenges remain. The concept of "Open Source AI", as defined by the Open Source Initiative after a thorough inclusive process, is crucial for fostering clarity and avoiding "open washing." Furthermore, the increasing popularity and ubiquity of open source bring greater responsibility.

Open Source: A Catalyst for European Innovation

Europe's developers are already leveraging open source to build innovative products and services. Open standards and collaborative development practices are fostering a vibrant ecosystem of startups and SMEs. This dynamic environment is essential for Europe's long-term competitiveness and its ability to shape the global digital landscape.

One promising avenue is the development of alternative, open source-based recommendation systems. These systems, built on principles of transparency and user control, can offer a viable alternative to the opaque algorithms of dominant platforms, potentially curbing the spread of misinformation and promoting a healthier information ecosystem. Projects like Tournesol or Mastodon, and more generally, of the Fedivrese, offer valuable examples of this approach, demonstrating how open source can empower users and foster a more diverse and democratic online space.

The Road Ahead: Collaboration and Investment

To fully realize the potential of AI and open source, Europe must:

  • Foster a thriving open source ecosystem: Continued investment in open source projects, particularly in critical areas like AI, is essential. This includes supporting the development of open source AI models, tools, and datasets. Public funding, such as the Cloud and AI Development Act proposed by M. Draghi, plays a vital role, but a long-term, sustainable funding model is needed. It should be noted that the open source ecosystem is currently fragile, relying heavily on the work of volunteers.
  • Promote diversity and inclusion: Ensuring that the open source community reflects the diversity of European society is crucial for fostering innovation and building truly inclusive technologies. Bridging the gender gap in the tech sector is a key aspect of this effort.
  • Define and promote "responsible and trustworthy" AI: Open source can be a powerful tool for building AI systems that are fair, transparent, and accountable. Europe can lead the way in defining and promoting ethical AI principles, leveraging open source as a key enabler. This may involve considering new licensing models specifically adapted to AI, while preserving the spirit of open source.
  • Facilitate collaboration: Close collaboration between policymakers, researchers, businesses, and the open source community is vital. Europe needs to foster a culture of openness, where knowledge is shared, and innovation thrives. This includes supporting initiatives that promote interoperability, such as the concept of "ungrouping" social media platforms to encourage the integration of open source solutions.
  • Invest in education and skills: Developing a workforce equipped with the skills needed to navigate the AI era is paramount. This includes promoting digital literacy and providing training in open source technologies.

Embracing the Open Source Opportunity

Open source is not just a technological choice; it's a strategic imperative. By embracing open source principles, Europe can build a digital future that is innovative, competitive, and aligned with its core values. The combination of AI and open source offers a unique opportunity to create a more inclusive, transparent, and ultimately, more prosperous digital society. As we move forward, let us seize this opportunity to shape a digital future where technology empowers all citizens, and where Europe stands as a global leader in responsible and ethical innovation. It is about fostering a model where we are not mere tenants, but collective owners of our digital future.

Addendum: The DeepSeek Shockwave (2025/01/27)

Last week, the emergence of DeepSeek, a Chinese startup, has sent ripples through the AI world. With a chatbot rivaling OpenAI's ChatGPT, but at a fraction of the cost and using less advanced hardware, it has challenged the perceived hegemony of resource-intensive AI development. This "DeepSeek shockwave," mirroring the historical "Sputnik moment," has led to market fluctuations and a reassessment of the AI landscape. It highlights a potential shift where efficiency and ingenuity might compete with, or even surpass, the brute-force approach of massive investments and cutting-edge hardware. Here are a few takeaways:

  • Democratized Accessibility through Open Source: DeepSeek exemplifies how open source can democratize access to advanced AI. By making powerful AI models available to a wider audience, it breaks down barriers to entry and fosters a more inclusive and innovative ecosystem. This accessibility is not limited to just using the models but also understanding, modifying, and building upon them.
  • Geopolitical Rebalancing Fueled by Open Innovation: DeepSeek's success, potentially driven by open source principles, demonstrates that the center of gravity in AI innovation might be shifting. China's strategic use of open source, coupled with efficient development practices, strengthens its position in the global tech race and challenges the dominance of Western tech giants. This will necessarily lead to a more multipolar AI landscape.
  • Efficiency as a Competitive Advantage: DeepSeek highlights that "bigger isn't always better." The project suggests that a focus on algorithmic efficiency, streamlined architectures, and optimized code can be just as, if not more, effective than simply throwing more resources at a problem. Open source fosters this efficiency by allowing for:
    • Collaborative Optimization: A global community of developers can contribute to refining algorithms, reducing redundancies, and optimizing performance.
    • Code Reusability: Developers can leverage existing open source libraries and frameworks, saving time and resources.
    • Reduced Development Costs: Open source eliminates licensing fees and allows for the sharing of development burdens.
    • Hardware Agnosticism: Open source AI models can potentially be more easily adapted to run on a variety of hardware, including less powerful and less expensive options as hinted by Deepseek's performances using older Nvidia chips. This is in contrast to some proprietary models that are tightly coupled to specific hardware, for example, Groq's model on their own chips.
  • Innovation Under Constraints: DeepSeek's development, partially constrained by external factors, showcases the power of ingenuity and resourcefulness. Open source, with its collaborative nature and adaptability, thrives under such constraints, fostering creative solutions and alternative approaches.
  • The Open Source Advantage in the AI Arms Race: The DeepSeek case suggests that open source could be a decisive factor in the global AI competition. By fostering collaboration, transparency, and efficiency, open source can accelerate innovation and potentially outpace closed, proprietary approaches that rely on massive resources and centralized control.
  • Strategic Implications for Europe: The rise of DeepSeek underscores the urgent need for Europe to double down on its commitment to open source AI. This involves:
    • Investing in open source AI research and development: Supporting projects, initiatives, and collaborations that advance the state of the art in open source AI.
    • Promoting the use of open source AI in industry and public services: Encouraging the adoption of open source solutions to foster innovation, competition, and digital sovereignty.
    • Developing clear ethical guidelines for open source AI: Ensuring that the development and deployment of open source AI align with European values.
    • Fostering a skilled workforce: Training developers and researchers in open source AI technologies.
  • Rethinking the Path to AI Supremacy: The traditional narrative of AI dominance being solely determined by massive compute resources and proprietary models is being challenged. DeepSeek's success so far suggests that a more distributed, open, and efficient approach, powered by open source, can be a viable, and even superior, path forward.

The DeepSeek phenomenon, especially if the open source nature of the project is confirmed, demonstrates that the future of AI might not be solely determined by the biggest budgets or the most powerful hardware, but by the ability to innovate efficiently, collaborate globally, and leverage the collective intelligence of the open source community. Europe, with its strong commitment to open source and its focus on ethical AI, is well-positioned to play a leading role in this new era.